As I was slowly reading Neal Pollack’s Alternadad (over the
last two months), I felt mild annoyance bubbling up in me nearly as often as
not. The whole clueless hipster “I just
leave that to my wife and fire up the bong because I’m selfish” confessional bent
that underlies the work is rendered only nominally less offensive because it’s
self-aware. And honestly, it seemed a
little rambling, although I definitely laughed out loud a few times and was
happy to see a couple of my pals referenced in one way or another.
A funny thing happened when I finished it yesterday though. All of a sudden I found the whole work hopelessly moving. It perfectly captures the rhythm of contemporary parenting: you try so hard, and as often as not so wrong (finding the “perfect” Montessori school, buying organic whole wheat crackers, providing just the right kind of rock-and-roll education), to do the best for your kid until the pressure builds and you have to relax the whole enterprise (crank up the Elmo, escape to Chicago on a bender, meet the other parents’ withering glares head on while acknowledging in the back of your head that they might be right). Maybe this is just where I’m at in my own life, but I found his account of the desperate attempt to balance self and devotion surprisingly valiant.
In the end, my crotchety old judgments seem kind of lame measured against that.




